Skip to content
← Back to listings
1057 Sheridan Ave photo 1
1 / 46 — Click to expand

1057 Sheridan Ave

1057 Sheridan Ave, Cody, WY · Park

$1,950,000ActiveCommercial

0.32

Acres

1965

Built

About This Property

1057 Sheridan Avenue presents an opportunity to acquire a fully leased, single-tenant Triple Net (NNN) investment property located along Sheridan Avenue in the heart of downtown Cody, Wyoming. Offered at $1,950,000, the property generates a current Net Operating Income of $149,250, representing a 7.65% capitalization rate, while providing investors with predictable cash flow, limited landlord responsibilities, and contractual income growth. The property is leased to Millstone Pizza Company, an established full-service restaurant, brewery, and sports bar serving both Cody's year-round residents and the region's thriving tourism economy. Under the existing Triple Net lease, the tenant is responsible for substantially all operating expenses, including real estate taxes, building insurance, maintenance, repairs, and utilities, creating a passive ownership structure with minimal ongoing management responsibilities. At today's asking price, those contractual rent adjustments provide projected cap rates of approximately 8.66%, 9.81%, and 11.10%, assuming renewal options are exercised and property-level expenses remain substantially consistent. Whether acquired as a passive investment, a 1031 exchange replacement property, or a long-term portfolio holding, 1057 Sheridan Avenue offers immediate income, contractual rent growth, and an attractive risk-adjusted return backed by an established operating business.

Estimated Monthly Payment

$11,554/mo

20% · $390,000
%
%
Principal & Interest $10,379
Property Tax (Est. 0.6%/yr)$975
Insurance (Est.)$200
Down Payment (20%) $390,000
Loan Amount $1,560,000

Estimate only. Based on 7.0% rate, 30-yr fixed, 20% down. Actual rates, taxes, insurance, and HOA may vary. Does not include PMI. Consult a lender for accurate figures. Source: standard amortization formula per §18.2.11.

Park County Market Snapshot

$685K

Median Price

18

Avg Days on Market

47

Active Listings

This property is listed at $1,950,000185% above median for Park County.

Source: Real Estate Outlaws market analysis. Not MLS data. Data approximate and subject to change.

Property Details

MLS #10030843
Property TypeCommercial
StatusActive
CountyPark
Year Built1965
Acreage0.32 acres
ListedSat Jan 18 2025 00:00:00 GM

Listed by REMAX Elevation · 307-855-1234 · Agent: Brenton Hayden

Source: Northwest Wyoming Board of REALTORS® MLS

Location

Living in Cody, Wyoming

Airport Access

About 3 miles to Yellowstone Regional Airport (COD), 5 min drive

Yellowstone

About 52 miles to Yellowstone East Gate, 1 hr drive

🎿

Recreation

Buffalo Bill Center of the West, Cody Stampede Rodeo, Shoshone National Forest, North Fork trails

🏫

Schools

Contact us for details on local schools and districts in the Cody area

Source: distances are approximate and based on typical driving conditions. Verify with local resources.

Want to See This Property?

Schedule a showing or ask us anything. We know the area like the back of our hand.

Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Listing data provided by the Northwest Wyoming Board of REALTORS® MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

© 2026 Northwest Wyoming Board of REALTORS®. All rights reserved.

REALTOR®Equal Housing Opportunity
Call